Back to Insights- UK trusts, tax and estate planning
- Media arts and culture
Longer Reads
How Stephen Hawking’s estate used his papers and office contents to settle millions in tax
James Cook and Jonathon Goldstone discuss how Stephen Hawking’s estate utilised the Acceptance in Lieu scheme in their recent article in EPrivateClient.
2 minute read
Published 15 June 2021
Key information
The media spotlight has focused on the estate of the late Professor Stephen Hawking recently due to a significant tax saving arrangement. An agreement was reached with the Cambridge University Library and the Science Museum Group for Hawking’s archives and the contents of his office to be preserved for posterity, with the objects given in lieu of inheritance tax under the “Acceptance in Lieu” scheme, run by the Arts Council of England.
In this article we will explore how this scheme works for inheritance tax planning, and also highlight its lifetime equivalent the “Cultural Gift” scheme. Finally, we will touch briefly on the Conditional Exemption Tax Incentive scheme. Together, these schemes aim to incentivise the retention of nationally important property in the UK.
The Acceptance in Lieu Scheme
The Acceptance in Lieu (AIL) scheme allows an estate to donate eligible property to an institution and have the value of that property offset against the estate’s inheritance tax liability. Eligibility is determined as follows:
- Is the property of “pre-eminent importance” owing to national, scientific, historic, or artistic significance (either alone or as part of a collection)
- Alternatively, is the property associated with an important historic public building or building belonging to certain charities (e.g. the National Trust)?
- For land or buildings, is it historically or architecturally important to national heritage?
The term “pre-eminent” means that the property is either an exceptional example of its type or perhaps an object without equivalent. An explanation of its pre-eminence will need to be given to the Arts Council within two years of the date of death, but it is for the Arts Council to decide whether they accept that definition.
Hawking’s papers are a clear example of a one-of-a-kind pre-eminent collection of scientific and historic importance (containing both his work papers and letters from Bill and Hilary Clinton and others). In contrast, an unremarkable piece of art by an otherwise remarkable artist, or if better examples are already preserved by museums or galleries, may not be eligible for the scheme.
The amount of tax that can be offset will depend on the value of the property donated,
though it is not a simple one-for-one exchange. Let us consider Hawking’s script from the
episode of The Simpsons in which he featured and assume this has a value of £10,000. If sold after death, the estate would potentially pay £4,000 in inheritance tax and receive a net benefit £6,000. If it is donated using the AIL scheme, the value of tax offset will be £6,000 plus 25 percent of the inheritance tax that would have been payable. The net benefit to the estate is £1,000 greater using the scheme.
But what if £10,000 is an underestimate? If someone would pay £20,000 at auction, then the estate would be better off taking this route and paying tax on the proceeds. Obtaining a
good (and accurate) valuation from the Arts Council is therefore crucial, and a great deal of work goes in to getting this right.
The Cultural Gift Scheme (CGS)
The lifetime equivalent of the AIL scheme is the CGS. This scheme works in a similar way to the AIL, in that there is a requirement for the Arts Council to agree the pre-eminent
importance of the specific items which would be acquired by relevant UK institutions.
However, instead of a refund of inheritance tax, the donated property can help to reduce the taxpayers income tax or capital gains tax liabilities (or corporation tax in the case of a
corporate donation).
For individuals, up to 30 percent of the value of the donation can be offset against these
taxes and this offset can be spread over the preceding 5 years. Although the CGS is less
generous than the AIL scheme, it covers a greater variety of taxes and offers a greater
degree of flexibility for taxpayers.
The Conditional Exemption Tax Incentive Scheme
The conditional exemption tax incentive scheme essentially allows assets or land of national importance (so-called “heritage property”) to remain outside the scope of inheritance tax and capital gains tax so long as their owners commit to preserve the assets for the public good. This will include an obligation to allow public access to the property for a certain number of days per year.
If Hawking’s heirs had wished, they could have applied to have his assets designated as
heritage property and then loaned them to the relevant institutions rather than donated
them. If the designation was accepted, the assets would remain the property of Hawking’s
heirs but would not have been subject to an inheritance tax charge. In sheer financial terms, this outcome is not as beneficial as the AIL scheme, but some estates may value retaining assets over maximising tax efficiency.
The various government backed incentive schemes are advantageous to the taxpayer from a financial perspective, but also help to ensure that their items of pre-eminent importance are preserved for future generations. The schemes are different in nature and thus it is
important for the adviser to engage with their client as soon as possible, preferably during
their lifetime, to determine the most appropriate incentive scheme to adopt.
This article first appeared in EPrivateClient in June 2021.
Related latest updates
PREV
NEXT
Shorter Reads
Read more
Election 2024: Initial comments on potential tax changes
Longer Reads
Read more
Piggy Banks to Portfolios: can children hold shares in a company?Shorter Reads
Read more
Stay or go? UK opposition’s tax hit on non-doms likely to encourage exodusShorter Reads
Read more
CB team comments on the Chancellor’s 2024 Spring BudgetLonger Reads
Read more
Destination UK: Tax tips & relocation advice
Shorter Reads
Read more
Can I make cash gifts under a power of attorney arrangement?
Longer Reads
Read more
Tax Justice UK proposes wealth tax to raise £37 billionPodcasts
Listen now
IRAs and how they work (Part 2)
Podcasts
Listen now
IRAs and how they work (Part 1)Shorter Reads
Read more
Gifts to Disabled and Vulnerable PeopleShorter Reads
Read more
Can I give my home to my children (and still live in it)?
Shorter Reads
Read more
US/UK givingShorter Reads
Read more
Gifts and Lasting Powers of Attorney (“LPAs”)Shorter Reads
Read more
Normal expenditure out of incomeShorter Reads
Read more
The perils of making a fortune at a tender ageShorter Reads
Read more
Gifting in the Arts (CGS v AIL)
Shorter Reads
Read more
How can I help my children buy a house?Shorter Reads
Read more
How should I approach charitable giving?Shorter Reads
Read more
Professor Stephen Hawking’s estate: Acceptance in Lieu in action
Longer Reads
Read more
UK – Tackling Tax AvoidanceShorter Reads
Read more
‘Tax Day’ – government continues its campaign to tackle non-complianceShorter Reads
Read more
Looking at the Budget 2021 from a Private client perspectiveLonger Reads
Read more
Shake up of CGT?Longer Reads
Read more
The prospect of further CGT changes – bad news for taxpayers, homeowners, and business owners?
Shorter Reads
Read more
Post-Brexit sanctions and the high net worth individualVideos
Watch now
Overview of English Inheritance Tax law – Part 2 (Turkish language)
Videos
Watch now
Overview of English Inheritance Tax law – Part 1 (Turkish language)Shorter Reads
Read more
Coronavirus – Can I create a Will while observing social distancing?Longer Reads
Read more
Coronavirus: Tax and Estate Planning Tips in the LockdownShorter Reads
Read more
Coronavirus: tax relief for the self-employedLonger Reads
Read more
Coronavirus – Can you create a Will while self-isolating?Shorter Reads
Read more
Are you ready for changes to Capital Gains Tax rules?
Related content
Longer Reads
How Stephen Hawking’s estate used his papers and office contents to settle millions in tax
James Cook and Jonathon Goldstone discuss how Stephen Hawking’s estate utilised the Acceptance in Lieu scheme in their recent article in EPrivateClient.
Published 15 June 2021
Associated sectors / services
The media spotlight has focused on the estate of the late Professor Stephen Hawking recently due to a significant tax saving arrangement. An agreement was reached with the Cambridge University Library and the Science Museum Group for Hawking’s archives and the contents of his office to be preserved for posterity, with the objects given in lieu of inheritance tax under the “Acceptance in Lieu” scheme, run by the Arts Council of England.
In this article we will explore how this scheme works for inheritance tax planning, and also highlight its lifetime equivalent the “Cultural Gift” scheme. Finally, we will touch briefly on the Conditional Exemption Tax Incentive scheme. Together, these schemes aim to incentivise the retention of nationally important property in the UK.
The Acceptance in Lieu Scheme
The Acceptance in Lieu (AIL) scheme allows an estate to donate eligible property to an institution and have the value of that property offset against the estate’s inheritance tax liability. Eligibility is determined as follows:
- Is the property of “pre-eminent importance” owing to national, scientific, historic, or artistic significance (either alone or as part of a collection)
- Alternatively, is the property associated with an important historic public building or building belonging to certain charities (e.g. the National Trust)?
- For land or buildings, is it historically or architecturally important to national heritage?
The term “pre-eminent” means that the property is either an exceptional example of its type or perhaps an object without equivalent. An explanation of its pre-eminence will need to be given to the Arts Council within two years of the date of death, but it is for the Arts Council to decide whether they accept that definition.
Hawking’s papers are a clear example of a one-of-a-kind pre-eminent collection of scientific and historic importance (containing both his work papers and letters from Bill and Hilary Clinton and others). In contrast, an unremarkable piece of art by an otherwise remarkable artist, or if better examples are already preserved by museums or galleries, may not be eligible for the scheme.
The amount of tax that can be offset will depend on the value of the property donated,
though it is not a simple one-for-one exchange. Let us consider Hawking’s script from the
episode of The Simpsons in which he featured and assume this has a value of £10,000. If sold after death, the estate would potentially pay £4,000 in inheritance tax and receive a net benefit £6,000. If it is donated using the AIL scheme, the value of tax offset will be £6,000 plus 25 percent of the inheritance tax that would have been payable. The net benefit to the estate is £1,000 greater using the scheme.
But what if £10,000 is an underestimate? If someone would pay £20,000 at auction, then the estate would be better off taking this route and paying tax on the proceeds. Obtaining a
good (and accurate) valuation from the Arts Council is therefore crucial, and a great deal of work goes in to getting this right.
The Cultural Gift Scheme (CGS)
The lifetime equivalent of the AIL scheme is the CGS. This scheme works in a similar way to the AIL, in that there is a requirement for the Arts Council to agree the pre-eminent
importance of the specific items which would be acquired by relevant UK institutions.
However, instead of a refund of inheritance tax, the donated property can help to reduce the taxpayers income tax or capital gains tax liabilities (or corporation tax in the case of a
corporate donation).
For individuals, up to 30 percent of the value of the donation can be offset against these
taxes and this offset can be spread over the preceding 5 years. Although the CGS is less
generous than the AIL scheme, it covers a greater variety of taxes and offers a greater
degree of flexibility for taxpayers.
The Conditional Exemption Tax Incentive Scheme
The conditional exemption tax incentive scheme essentially allows assets or land of national importance (so-called “heritage property”) to remain outside the scope of inheritance tax and capital gains tax so long as their owners commit to preserve the assets for the public good. This will include an obligation to allow public access to the property for a certain number of days per year.
If Hawking’s heirs had wished, they could have applied to have his assets designated as
heritage property and then loaned them to the relevant institutions rather than donated
them. If the designation was accepted, the assets would remain the property of Hawking’s
heirs but would not have been subject to an inheritance tax charge. In sheer financial terms, this outcome is not as beneficial as the AIL scheme, but some estates may value retaining assets over maximising tax efficiency.
The various government backed incentive schemes are advantageous to the taxpayer from a financial perspective, but also help to ensure that their items of pre-eminent importance are preserved for future generations. The schemes are different in nature and thus it is
important for the adviser to engage with their client as soon as possible, preferably during
their lifetime, to determine the most appropriate incentive scheme to adopt.
This article first appeared in EPrivateClient in June 2021.
Associated sectors / services
- UK trusts, tax and estate planning
- Media arts and culture
Need some more information? Make an enquiry below.
Enjoy reading our articles? why not subscribe to notifications so you’ll never miss one?
Subscribe to our articlesMessage us on WhatsApp (calling not available)
Please note that Collyer Bristow provides this service during office hours for general information and enquiries only and that no legal or other professional advice will be provided over the WhatsApp platform. Please also note that if you choose to use this platform your personal data is likely to be processed outside the UK and EEA, including in the US. Appropriate legal or other professional opinion should be taken before taking or omitting to take any action in respect of any specific problem. Collyer Bristow LLP accepts no liability for any loss or damage which may arise from reliance on information provided. All information will be deleted immediately upon completion of a conversation.
Close
